K = The Knife of Never Letting Go by Patrick Ness
The Knife of Never Letting Go (Chaos Walking #1) by Patrick Ness
"That's the thing I'm learning about being thrown out on your own. Nobody does nothing for you. If you don't change it, it don't get changed."
Todd Hewwit knows a lot of things: he knows a group of settlers left the Old World for the New World, to live a simpler existence away from the evils of society. He knows there was a war between the native people, The Spackles, and the humans. He knows The Spackles used Germ Warfare; releasing bugs that turned the internal monologues of men into never ending Noise, while killing off all the women, and giving animals the power to speak. He knows The Spackles were eventually defeated, leaving Prentisstown the only surviving settlement.
Todd, the youngest member of Prentisstown, is eagerly awaiting the arrival of his thirteenth birthday, where he will officially be considered a man. But when Todd and his dog Manchee discover a hole in the Noise, he learns that everything he knows is a lie and he is forced to run for his life.
I absolutely adored this book, I couldn't put it down. Let me tell you why.
I love the frustrating air of mystery and danger around everything. If Todd goes apple picking he could get eaten by crocs just as easily as being slapped around by a madman. Then the hole in the noise. A quiet that moves. A convoluted concept that made me want to scream, "What the hell is it!" I like Todd as a hero; he's not a bad guy, but he's not pure as the driven snow: he is a teenager. He's prone to ragey tantrums; I appreciate the realism. Adolescence is a time for emotional fits-- Puberty's a bitch. Add in the knowledge that everyone is lying and nobody wants to explain why, and it jumps beyond realism. I feel the anger, the betrayal, and my heart breaks for Todd. All he's got left is his dog and--
But I can't tell you who the AND is...the And is a big spoiler. I try to avoid those.
This book doesn't waste any time moving right along; no long drawn out explanations for anything, even when you really really want them. It is suspenseful; the pages kept turning because I wanted the answers as much as I want to see where the adventure leads.The explanations as to why things are the way they are, get dropped when its most convenient for the author, when its most helpful to the story. There's plenty of humor, mixed into the darkness, but there's plenty of darkness too.
I'd also like to address the thing most of the negative reviewers addressed: grammar and spelling. The grammar isn't perfect. There are fairly obvious spelling mistakes and extreme run on sentences. I'm usually one of the first people in the flaming-grammar-problems-party-- I'll bring the Sterno, you cook the s'mores. I don't take abuse of the English Language lightly, so when I say I loved this book, I mean errors included. Because this story is told from the POV of a teenage boy who hasn't had an education. In Prentisstown, knowledge is considered a dangerous thing; books were burned, a schoolhouse closed. Todd can't read, he can't write. So he rambles, he uses slang, he makes spelling and pronunciation mistakes. I would expect that from a kid who can't read or write. So the mistakes in this book are beautiful to me; to me it shows a well developed character and I'd never insult that. I live for the characters. The more depth the better. And if the people who insulted the writing style finished the book, or even made it halfway through, they must know Todd can't read...So why cause such a fuss?
All I can tell you is that there is emotionally wrought adventure to be had on another planet, with a teenage boy and his comical talking dog. And if you like young heroes facing long odds, lots of drama, and a bit of bloodshed, you aren't doing yourself any favors by avoiding this book. I can also tell you, I immediately downloaded Book 2 because the ending of Book 1 made my Top 3 list of cruel cliffhangers.If there's one reason to be irritated at Patrick Ness, it was that ending. Who ends a book like that?
I love heroes facing long odds, and I love young adult stories. Add mystery and adventure and danger, and it's something I'm going to want to read. I'm reading a book right now that I'm not enjoying at all, and I was trying to figure out why. There's a mystery involved, and I guess there could be danger, though I'm not sensing any.
ReplyDeleteLogic tells me another character could get killed, but I don't think it would be the main character, so I'm not invested in the idea of any possible danger coming.
I was thinking about it the other day, knowing I need to write an honest review for one of my future blog posts. I tried to figure out what it is about the book that I don't like. I mean, there is a murder. There is mystery. There's some investigating. There's one character I absolutely love, though she's not the main character.
I finally figured it out, the thing that is missing and making this book a snore. It lacks tension. It's not enough to say that somebody was murdered and for the reader's logic to kick in and realize it might happen again, although no threat has been posed. But it's not enough to know it. You have to feel the tension, feel the possibility that a knife might be coming your way any second. I feel nothing like that reading this book. Usually, I just feel tired. Some nights I fall asleep after five pages. But I am determined to finish.
Thank you for the review of this book. It gives me something to look forward to that I can count on to kick up the adrenaline.
What book are you reading right now?
DeleteIt's awful when you're struggling to push through a book thats forcing you to take a nap with every page and then your honest review becomes, "this book and everything that was wrong with it."
I hope you like this one better than that one.
X, by Sue Grafton. I will be writing a review on it for the latter X, and it will be an honest review. But I will never write a review that is 100% negative. There's always something good I can say, but I will be honest on why it's a snore to me. Mostly I believe it's because I read a description of it that sounded like a thriller. But in actuality, I believe it's a cozy. So my expectations were quite different than what I got. Maybe had I gone into it knowing it was a cozy, I would've felt differently about it. But I don't really read cozies.
DeleteI don't get people who complain about grammar and spelling when it's clear that was the intent. They so miss the point. Thanks for the cliffhanger warning. I hate them intensely unless I know it's coming. (I don't need to be spoiled, but let me know that the ending isn't a resolution before hand. If I'm pissed off enough, I won't continue the series.)
ReplyDeleteThey piss me off too. all that build up, to go to a non-ending. and if the book wasn't good enough to be bothered with reading the next in line then you never know what the conclusion of the first book could have been until the second story...which you probably aren't reading.
DeleteIts such a nuanced way of writing, where you are able to give a thorough review and yet not spoil the fun
ReplyDeleteI try to avoid spoilers but sadly i don't always succeed.
DeleteI usually avoid books that have animals in them (almost every time something bad happens to the animal or I'm worried throughout the book that something will happen that I don't enjoy the story), but this sounds like a great read so I might have to consider reading it even with a dog.
ReplyDeleteDon't read it, if you're going to hate something bad happening to animals. Your heart will get ripped from your chest.
DeleteI'm a binge-reader, so I won't start a series until all the books are out -- otherwise cliffhangers drive me up a wall.
ReplyDeleteRonel visiting for K: My Languishing TBR: K
Two-Faced Kishi
Me less so, depending on the quality of the series I'm okay with taking breaks. But all three books are out, if you'd like to read this one.
Delete